Finding True Refuge

A mindfulness tool that offers support for working with difficult emotionsTara Brach

Wisdom Collection

To access the content within the Wisdom Collection,
join Tricycle as a Supporting or Sustaining Member

Watch our new video teachings by the author of this article, Tara Brach, here. From 2/11 to 2/17, she'll be available to answer questions online, so don't be afraid to ask! Please post your questions on the video teachings page linked to above.


Matt Walford


Cultivate flexibility.

You have a unique body and mind, with a particular history and conditioning. No one can offer you a formula for navigating all situations and all states of mind. Only by listening inwardly in a fresh and open way will you discern at any given time what most serves your healing and freedom.

As you practice RAIN, keep in mind that the sequence I’ve suggested is neither rigid nor necessarily linear; you may need to adapt the order as you attend to your inner experience. You might find, for instance, that as soon as you feel rising anxiety, you recognize it as a familiar inner weather pattern that happens to you and most everyone you know, and hence does not feel so “personal.” In moments like these you have already arrived at the N of RAIN; so rather than any continued “doing” such as investigating with kindness, you might simply rest in natural presence. Similarly, you might end your RAIN practice before formally moving through all the steps, or you might cycle through the process again if you encounter something unexpected.

As you listen inwardly to what is needed, you may also feel drawn to weave other forms of meditation into your practice of RAIN. To ground yourself, you might begin with a body-based reflection, yoga, or a walking meditation. If strong feelings arise in the midst of RAIN, you might take some time to simply focus on your breath. Or you might find that a few minutes of lovingkindness practice help you to bring a gentler and more compassionate attention to investigation. This kind of inner listening and adaptability can help you transform what at first might seem to be a mechanical technique into a creative and vibrant means of awakening on your spiritual path.

Practice with the "small stuff."

The 6th-century Buddhist master Shantideva suggested that by staying present “with little cares, we train ourselves to work with great adversity.” Each time you bring RAIN to a situation that usually causes you to react, you strengthen your capacity to awaken from trance. You might identify in advance what, to you, is chronic “small stuff”—the annoyance that comes up when someone repeats themselves, the restlessness when you are waiting in line, the frustration when you’ve forgotten to pick up something on your shopping list—and commit to pausing and practicing a “light” version of RAIN. By pausing many times throughout the day and bringing an interest and presence to your habitual ways of reacting, your life will become increasingly spontaneous and free.

Seek help.

Practicing RAIN can intensify your emotional experience. If you are concerned that you might become overwhelmed by your feelings, postpone practicing RAIN alone and seek help. Particularly if you are working with post-traumatic stress, it can be important, and even necessary, to have the support of a therapist or a psychologically attuned meditation teacher. The presence of a trusted and experienced person can help you feel safe enough to connect with inner vulnerability and also help you to find relief if what arises feels like “too much.”

Let your senses be a gateway to presence.

The practice of RAIN comes alive as you learn to step out of your thoughts and connect with your body’s experience. Many people move through daily life obsessed with thoughts and, to varying degrees, dissociated from the felt sense in the body. Strong emotional trauma or wounding makes dissociation from bodily awareness particularly likely. Whether you are working through deep fear and shame or a less acute emotional reaction, your inner freedom will arise from bringing attention to how the experience is expressed in your body. On my evening walk, the pivotal moment came when I could directly feel how layers of judgment, assumed unworthiness, and grief were squeezing my heart.

Be mindful of doubt.

Doubt acts as a main impediment to RAIN and more broadly, to any gateway of true refuge. The Buddha considered doubt (along with clinging and aversion) to be a universal “hindrance” to spiritual freedom. When you are stuck in beliefs like “I’m never going to change,” “I’m not cut out for spiritual practice,” or “Healing and freedom aren’t really possible,” you get stopped in your tracks.

Needless to say, some doubt is healthy, as in “I’m no longer certain this job is in line with my values,” or “Maybe I’ve been the one who is avoiding intimacy,” or “I wonder whether I can trust a spiritual teacher who speaks disrespectfully of other teachers.” Like investigation, healthy doubt arises from the urge to know what is true—it challenges assumptions or the status quo in service of healing and freedom. In contrast, unhealthy doubt arises from fear and aversion, and it questions one’s own basic potential or worth, or the value of another.

When unhealthy doubt arises, let it be the subject of RAIN. It helps to say to yourself, “This is doubt,” consciously acknowledging its presence in your mind. By recognizing and naming doubt when it arises but not judging it, you immediately enlarge your perspective and loosen the bind of trance. If the doubt is persistent, you can deepen presence by regarding it with kindness. Rather than being controlled and perhaps paralyzed by doubt, let it be a call for clear, mindful presence.

Be patient.

Patience gives you joy in the process of awakening. Without patience, you may find yourself at war with your own forgetfulness or reactivity. Long-term meditators or therapy clients often complain, “I’ve been dealing with this same issue for decades.” They are troubled by their “regressions” into old feelings of being worthless or rejected, unsafe or ashamed. Such bouts of trance can be accompanied by desperation and the fear that there will be no end to the cycling of unhealthy patterns of feelings and behaviors. While RAIN reduces the grip of trance, it is rarely a one-shot experience. You may need to go through numerous rounds of RAIN, again and again meeting entrenched patterns of suffering with attention and kindness.

The belief and feeling that “something is wrong with me” was a key theme in my first book, Radical Acceptance, and this feeling continues to be part of my life. But my many rounds of meeting it with presence have had an effect: the trance is much more transparent, short-lived, and suffering-free. Often it makes a brief appearance, and then there’s recognition, “Ah, this again…” and a letting go. It’s not that “I” am letting go, but rather the old false sense of self just dissolves when it is seen. What remains is an invigorated realization of the heart-space that holds this life, and a trust in the tender awareness that lives beyond the trance.

Each time you meet an old emotional pattern with presence, your awakening to truth can deepen. There’s less identification with the self in the story and more ability to rest in the awareness that is witnessing what’s happening. You become more able to abide in compassion, to remember and trust your true home. Rather than cycling repetitively through old conditioning, you are actually spiraling toward freedom.

Be sincere.

An attitude of sincerity in approaching spiritual practices like RAIN orients your heart and mind toward freedom. Let yourself recall again and again what for you is “the most important thing.” Perhaps you long to realize the truth of who you are, to love well, to touch peace, or to live more from presence. Whatever you most care about, let this tenderness of heart energize your meditation. The sincerity of your longing will carry you home.

Tara Brach has practiced and taught meditation for over 35 years. She is the senior teacher and founder of the Insight Meditation Community of Washington, D.C. This article was adapted from True Refuge: Finding Peace and Freedom in Your Awakened Heart by Tara Brach © 2013. Printed with permission of Bantam Books, an imprint of The Random House Publishing Group.

Photographs by Matt Walford.

Share with a Friend

Email to a Friend

Already a member? Log in to share this content.

You must be a Tricycle Community member to use this feature.

1. Join as a Basic Member

Signing up to Tricycle newsletters will enroll you as a free Tricycle Basic Member.You can opt out of our emails at any time from your account screen.

2. Enter Your Message Details

Enter multiple email addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
Tara Brach's picture

Hi "Searching"

I want to honor your awareness of what is unfolding, and your "caring about caring." Your heart, that loving presence, is there. Just not in a way that you can discern.

Is it possible to let it be okay that this is not a season of feeling loving feelings, to forgive the inner weather systems for being as they are? Forgive does not presume wrong-doing, rather it is a letting go of the expectation that things should be different. That you should be different. Just as we might put a hand on our heart and send a loving blessings you might explore putting your hand on your heart and forgiving that it is closed at this point.

It's natural to want things different, to want to feel loving. But what if you forgave what is, and met the experience with curiosity? What if you investigated the sense of being cut off--the anxiety and fear that surrounds it-- asking how those experiences wanted you to be with them?

Whatever is happening can be a portal to freedom--to deepened trust in who we are--if we surrender into letting it be there, and open to what is with mindfulness. Naturally there are wise, skillful supports, such as our friend zipporah mentions. And..the bottom line is making peace with how it is right now...trusting that this too is part of the path and that presence with it can carry you home. Wishing you all blessings on the journey. With love, Tara

Searching's picture

Hey Tara,

First off thanks so much for this amazing article. There is no doubt that it will be of extreme benefit for all of us! I just have one personal concern…and a pretty big one at that.

What if I were to tell that I had been practicing exactly as you have suggested through the RAIN approach, and it was allowing me to live life in the most meaningful way…with a complete sense of openness and unconditional love for all of creation…However, at some point along the way, what I am guessing was anxiety crept in, and I wasn’t able to approach it as I normally do…for some reason, this sensation has been escalating since that point and it has reached a situation where I cannot feel love…I feel completely dead inside and can only feel “negative” emotions…and from what you have said, and from what I know, LOVE towards self and other (for ex. the step of investigating with kindness) is the key…but what if you can no longer generate that love, or find that love within you? (and I have tried what I feel is every approach to unconditional love, but I simply cannot feel anything)…and so I have been living in a perpetual (24-7) sense of anxiety, anguish, fear because I know I should be feeling love…and that’s the other big part of the problem… I KNOW so much cognitively, but I cannot feel (anything “positive” ie. gentleness, tenderness, joy, etc)…almost a complete disconnect, a bystander watching but not engaging with life…any insight would be saving grace.

zipport's picture

Hello "Searching",
I just read your response to Tara Brach's article and feel moved to respond. I have had several bouts of depression in my life, and what you are describing is just what I have felt in depression. I have been advised by different health professionals to take medication which I resisted for a long time. But I finally accepted their advice and have been taking very small doses of two antidepressants. I wonder if you might need that support to get out of the pit you have fallen into. Other practices have also helped me. The Lovingkindess meditation, imagining myself in the middle of a circle of spritual beings who are saying the prayer to me. Also the mantra, "Love and Gratitude" to remind myself that I experience those feelings in my life. When I am in a depression, I am very identified with the negative emotions and judgments of myself, and that feels like the Truth. I'm sure that Tara will respond to your cry for help. Please know that this state of mind will pass, and you will feel your love again. I hope that this is of some benefit to you.
with metta,
zipporah

Searching's picture

And forgive me if any of this is incoherent as my mind has been in complete agitation for so long now

(furthermore I do many things such as yoga, running, deep breathing...but to no avail?)

noradhussey's picture

I am writing in reply to all of you as I agree with both Tara and Z
The anxiety that is going along with your feeling of apathy which is what it sounds like (inability to feel love) rings very true to clinical depression and yes medication along with talk therapy certainly can be very helpful and I would not rule it out. At the same time if you are able to allow yourself as Tara said to step back and dissasociate and examine the fact that you are experiencing this without judgement and know that it will eventually change as nothing remains the same. With persistant practice and support this may work on its own. Never feel you are a failure though if you reach out to the Western support therapy in conjunction with mindiful meditation. As stated in the article those of us with PTSD may indeed need to have an additional support system engaged to begin. We are now using Mindfulness with our PTSD soldiers and I myself am a veteran who along with the loss of the military am losing a marriage of 47 years. I am readily taking all comers for help. It is a journey and for me there has been a need to include some Rx adjuncts to the mindful meditation. It is the meditation though that has been lifesaving. Do not judge yourself just let it be and be compassionate with you. It has taken me a long time to do that but it was worth the effort.