Ah, But the Breezes . . .

Noelle Oxenhandler offers huge praise for the small word but.

Noelle Oxenhandler

© Bradford Washburn

Often a spiritual quest begins with the word but. I have everything I need to make me happy, but I am not happy . . .

For my neighbor Sally, the quest began many years ago in a villa in southern France. It was a beautiful villa, covered with bougainvillea and facing the Mediterranean, and she was in the company of loving friends. “But I just couldn’t be happy,” she remembers. One restless, fitful night, she came across a book left behind by a previous guest. It was The Autobiography of a Yogi, and it led her to the practice that she has followed ever since. As for Prince Siddhartha: His parents made sure that he had everything on earth to make him happy. He lived in a beautiful palace and roamed through lush gardens and enjoyed the company of loving friends and bountiful food and . . .

Notice the and’s? They were not enough to keep the but from his life.

The but of an old man, a sick man, a corpse . . .

One day these sights pierced through the shield of and’s that the king and queen had made for their son. The minarets and the marble, the jasmine and honeysuckle, the silks and sweets, the laughter, music, and dancing: All these could not shield the prince from the but of suffering that he discovered outside the palace gate.

Outside: The word but derives from the Latin ob, meaning “out.” Suffering is what we want to keep out, but somehow it always gets into our lives.

It doesn’t always come in a strong dose. Sometimes it’s subtle, homeopathic.

When I was fifteen, I fell in love with a boy I met when I twisted my ankle and my ski went flying over a cliff in the Haute-Savoie mountains in France. A handsome, dark-haired boy took off over the cliff and, nearly an hour later, handed me the ski that had plunged into a deep ravine. His name was Michel.

He attended a Jesuit boarding school in the nearby village, where he’d been sent for being unruly. When I visited him there, in his cell-like room, he read me the poems of his favorite poet, Rimbaud, the “enfant terrible.” Then he showed me the secret stash of candy and cigarettes that he kept in a hollowed-out Bible. We went to the Mardi Gras celebration at his school that night, and he went as Lazarus, wrapped in a white sheet. That was Michel, always defying something: a sheer cliff, a school’s rules, the idea of death . . .

We met several times again that year when Michel was visiting his parents in Paris, which was where my family was spending the year. Shortly before our return to California, Michel’s parents invited me to spend the following summer with them in their chalet in the high French Alps.

Now, between our handful of vivid moments from the past and the summer’s wide-open future, Michel and I had just enough raw matter to spin a dense web of fantasy. Back in California, I set my alarm clock an hour early on school nights so I’d have time to wake up and read his letters and to imagine, again and again, the scene of our reunion. After a long journey, my train pulls up to the village station. Through the window I see a stone clock-tower, surrounded by white mountain peaks. And there he is. Waiting for me on the platform: handsome, dark-haired Michel. I step off the train, and we rush into each other’s arms.

At last the long school year came to an end, and I flew to Paris by myself and took the night train that winds through the heart of France, from Paris all the way to Provence. Too excited to sleep on my narrow berth, I lay there in the dark, wrapped in my web of revery.

At dawn’s light, I looked out and saw meadows of wildflowers flying by, villages built of dark wood and stone, and brilliant white peaks in the distance. . .

By late morning, the train arrived at the tiny village called Puy-St. Vincent. I stepped off the train and there he was, waiting for me: handsome, dark-haired Michel. We rushed toward each other, just as I had imagined. But in the moment of embracing him, I looked over his shoulder and saw a small pink plastic lobster lying on the ground. Even in the bliss of being in his arms, I felt the shock of the alien thing, the thing that—in all those hours of daydreaming—I’d never once imagined.

It is thirty-four years since I stepped off the train in Puy-St. Vincent, and Michel died long ago in an avalanche on Mt. Everest. Yet there’s a way that the moment of seeing the small pink lobster over his shoulder has happened again and again.

It’s the moment of the but. The moment when something outside the pale of our own dreams, desires, expectations, intrudes. “But this wasn’t in my plans! This is not what I had in mind!” Indeed, that summer in the Alps bore no resemblance to the summer I’d set my clock to dream of, morning after morning, in California. Unable to live up to the months of fantasy, my relationship with Michel quickly unraveled—and there I was, far from home, stuck for weeks in a house with a sullen boy who barely spoke to me. Looking back, it would be easy to see the lobster as a sinister omen. Yet from the first moment, I sensed it was a different kind of messenger. I didn’t have words for it then, but somehow I knew that this was a small monster calling to me with life’s big question: Can you include the outside, alien thing in the embrace?

To truly answer this question is to come up against the very edge of the human psyche. For from the very beginning, what we desire is and. The very opposite of but, the word and is linked to “in,” and our life begins in utero. For the human infant, bliss is the and that comes as close as possible to that primal in: I am here and you are here and when I open my mouth your milk is in me and I am in your arms.

Alas, from the very beginning, the but intrudes. Even the most attentive mother cannot fail to fail her infant at times: A hungry stomach aches, a wet diaper chafes, the bath water is too hot or too cold. . . In the mouth of even the luckiest baby, sharp teeth soon intrude in the soft site of pleasure.

Yet our whole lives long, we go on wanting a version of the primal and. We fall in love, and we think we’ve found it again. My first two weeks in Puy-St. Vincent were blissful. Michel and I swam in deep blue mountain lakes and hiked to where the world seemed nothing but glacier, rock, and clouds. Following the sound of a hundred small bells, we found the trail that led to the village shepherd: Bernard, a young man who spent his life alone with a hundred sheep. Back in the village, we had long, communal meals with his family and neighbors; we played volleyball in the evenings as the snowy mountains turned a flamboyant pink; we joined with other teenagers to help restore the crumbling Roman chapel, polishing old paintings with raw potato halves and hearing each other’s mock confessions in the carved wooden booth. As a gift to Michel’s family, I’d brought a beautiful white Mexican wedding hammock. Michel hung it up between two pine trees, and we loved to lie in it, swinging out over the blue valley, murmuring to each other as we’d longed to during all those months of ink on paper. Whatever the words, in English or French, their import was this: You are here and I am here and you are in my arms and I am in your arms and this moment will go on and on and on.

Share with a Friend

Email to a Friend

Already a member? Log in to share this content.

You must be a Tricycle Community member to use this feature.

1. Join as a Basic Member

Signing up to Tricycle newsletters will enroll you as a free Tricycle Basic Member.You can opt out of our emails at any time from your account screen.

2. Enter Your Message Details

Enter multiple email addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.