August 06, 2010
Himalayan Art Resources (HAR) is the most comprehensive collection of Himalayan art available, much of it Buddhist. For years now, Jeff Watt, HAR's director, has been exhorting us to understand and critique Himalayan art on its own merit—much as we might consider, say, a Fra Angelico—and rescue it from the theory-laden university art history departments. For support, Jeff refers us to to an article in yesterday's New York Times, in which Laurence Kantner, an expert in early Italian painting and former curator at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, has this to say:
"Art history has been hijacked by other disciplines,” said Mr. Kanter, who teaches a connoisseurship seminar tograduate students. “Original works of art have been forgotten. They’re being used as data, without any sense of whether they’re good, bad or indifferent.”
Katner has organized an exhibition of some 60 paintings from the collection of prominent collector Richard Feigen, who, on the power of his own eye for quality, once bought a painting thought to be the work of a "minor Italian painter" that turned out to be a Fra Angelico. The show Katner organized for the Yale University Art Gallery, is "part of a campaign to bring old-fashioned connoisseurship back into the academy, which [Kantner and Feigen] consider to be a thicket overgrown with abstruse theories." According to Feigen, himself the consummate connoisseur, "There isn’t a single art history department in the world that I consider first-class.”
Jeff Watt probably agrees. He has this to say, referring to the Times article:
[W]e also agree that in the field of Himalayan and Tibetan art studies, the art has been hijacked by other academic disciplines such as Religious Studies (and the study of iconography), Anthropology and Ethnography. The art itself has become relegated to being mere data and props for the discussion of ideas and theories. As the NYT article says, "data versus connoisseurship". This article is a wake up call, timely and refreshing.
Of course, he has a lot more to say, too, so have a look.